Key Issues

Less to fear and more to gain from immigration

This coming May will see ten new countries join the EU, eight of them from central-eastern Europe. National tabloids have already predicted the outcome: floods or better still, swarms of disease ridden migrants will be entering the UK using cheap flight tickets and making a bee-line for the welfare payments. As if this were not enough, they will also steal British jobs, housing and, no doubt, whatever else they can lay their hands on!

If this wasn't so utterly misleading and deadly serious, this farce might almost be laughable. Indiscriminate scaremongering is not only misleading and shameful; it will hardly endear us to our new European neighbours.

A recent comprehensive survey has shown that were conditions of full free movement applied across the current Member States, actual migration from the new Member States would be around 1% of their population - that means around 220.000 a year spread over the 15 existing member states. This is rather different to the millions suggested by the British press. There is also evidence to show that a considerable number of those with a firm intention of seeking employment in the older Member States are young, educated to tertiary level and free from dependents.

This implies more opportunities than risks for the older Member States, The losers in this equation are inevitably the new Member States and their economies, as they haemorrhage educated young workers to the West. Those European countries that stick by their initial promise to open up their labour markets (and this includes the UK), will ultimately be in a position to alleviate shortages in some sectors of their labour markets. Whilst immigration can, undeniably, offset some demographic problems in Europe, it is by no means a solution. There is a strong need for policies that couple immigration with broader labour market reforms. These include better integration of ethnic minorities and already settled migrants into the workforce and improved training opportunities. Those with parental responsibilities also need to receive more support from government and employers, which would enable them to successfully combine work and family life.

Thus Member States should encourage free movement of labour while taking the effects on the sending countries into account. The onus needs to be on adopting regional and structural measures geared towards improving economic growth in the new member states. This could reduce the incentive to leave and contribute to long-term economic benefits for the Union as a whole. Such measures need not imply restrictions on labour mobility, which is anchored in the European treaties, but rather a more holistic approach to immigration and integration.

The UK government could improve its coordination with representatives of both sides of industry and organisations that aim to improve the integration process. The trade unions unique position enables them to address developments within the labour market and defend the rights of national and immigrant workers. Other programmes such as EQUAL, which is funded by the European Social Fund, work at a European, national and regional level to improve social and employment conditions for immigrants. Perhaps more importantly, there is a real need for an open discussion about immigration instead of it being used to spread distrust and sell tabloids.  We need to create a general understanding of the mutual advantages and disadvantages of a well-managed immigration policy. It is in everyone's interest to achieve these goals - the greatest overall economic, social and cultural contribution comes from well integrated immigrants.

Only by having the courage to defend labour mobility in the face off ill-founded public unease and challenge misconceptions that pander to right-wing sentiment will European societies be able to have an open debate about the reciprocal costs and benefits of immigration.

It is crucial that the myths associated with immigration are dispelled: Immigrants will not steal jobs nor disproportionately burden the welfare system. Those who actually make the difficult decision to move away from their home countries are keen to work hard and improve their prospects, often bringing valuable skills to the host countries. In order to realise the goals of the Lisbon Strategy, free movement of labour within the EU is essential. If the UK and other EU members are serious about the idea of a strong, social Europe then they must take a more honest and progressive stance towards the free movement of labour. This also means guaranteed social rights for ´all´ its citizens.

Those who can successfully manage immigration and embrace cultural diversity will benefit not only from increased competitively but also from the positive exchange of cultural experiences and values. Defending pluralist and social ideals will help counteract racist tendencies that often stem from exaggerated fears and mistrust of the unknown. The BNP and similar right-wing parties within Europe thrive on these weaknesses and as such, it is in all of our interests to defend the  principles of a better society. The success of European enlargement and our relations with other countries depends on our ability to welcome foreigners and enable them to participate in civil society.






Previous Press releases + articles:

(26.07.13) - Labour MEPs support budget for jobs and growth

(24.07.13) - Labour MEPs vote to make Europe's roads safer

(23.07.13) - Tories and Lib Dems vote down arms control measures

(05.07.13) - Historic Vote on new transparency rules for the extractive industries



(01.03.13) - Labour MEPs welcome today's Europe-wide 'Youth Guarantee'

(22.2.13) - Fish campaigners win EU 'discard' vote

(21.12.12) - Oppression of Trade Unionist Leads to Labour Rejection of Trade Agreement

(20.12.12) - Labour MEPs vote to increase animal welfare by limiting animal transport journeys

(12.10.12) - Hughes joins guitarist Brian May to stop "unnecessary badger cull"

(08.10.12) - MEP welcomes major report on trans and intersex people

(19.07.12) - "eCall" crash sysem could save lives

(19.07.12) - Access to Basic Banking is a Consumer Right says MEP

(19.07.12) - Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement

(19.06.12) - Follow on Formula Milk

(25.05.12) - Online Platform on Viral Hepatitis and Liver Cancer

(10.05.12) - Labour MEPs Take Action on EU Spending

(19.04.12) - Viral Hepatitis and Liver Cancer Expert Platform

(13.03.12) - Fairtrade Fortnight

(01.02.12) - VAT on e-books

(02.02.12) - MEP calls for EU-sponsored action to prevent cancer in 2012

(19.1.12) - MEP calls on Government to make recycling electronic waste easier

(16.12.11) - Stephen Hughes signs Equal Love Petitiion

(19.12.11) - Stephen Hughes welcomes the clean up in our regional water

(19.12.11) - Labour support EU-wide rights for whistleblowers

(19.12.11) - Britain is paying the price for Cameron's isolationism

(15.11.11) - Commission Fails to Act on Animal Welfare

(10.11.11) - Aster Fissehatsion

(08.11.11) - Euro Trade Register

(03.11.11) - Europe Means Responsible Business

(07.10.11) - Robin Hood Tax

(06.10.11) - Financial Transaction Tax

(29.09.11) - Agency Workers

(13.09.11) - Help Whistleblowers to prevent North Sea Oil Spills

(05.07.11) - Consumers win right to know origins of their Sunday roast

(22.06.11) - Stephen Hughes backs Fish Fight Chef's Campaign

(09.06.11) - Call for Action after small businesses in North East billed for thousands

(07.06.11) - European Arrest Warrants

(13.05.11) - Call for Action to Bring Fish Back to Our Seas

(12.05.11) - Call for Action in Fight Against Fraudsters

(21.04.11) - EU must end spurious Arrest Warrants

(07.04.11) - EU gives boost to North East Farmers

(31.03.11) - Cloning in the Food Chain

(31.03.11) - Victims' Rights Campaign for Brits Abroad

(29.03.11) - Baby Milk Eye Sight Claim

(15.03.11) - Foreign Drivers on North East Roads

(04.02.11) - EU must do more to tackle Alzheimer's

(03.02.11) - EU Targets to Tackle Mobile Phone Waste

(18.01.11) - EU Standards on Building Materials

(20.12.10) - EU Consumer Rights

(08.12.10) - Bus and Coach Passengers New EU Rules

(04.11.10) - Misuse of EU Funds

(30-9-10) - EU Proceedings Against France on The Roma

(09.09.10) - New Animal Testing Rules "Missed Opportunity"

(09.07.10) - New Rights for Boat, Bus and Coach Passengers

(01.07.10) - EU Mobile Phone Roaming Charges

(19.06.10) - Action to Stop Trade in Torture Instruments

(18.06.10) - Food Labelling

(16.6.10) - Translation Rules to Make EU Trials Fairer

(08.04.10) - Sort out Spanish Property Problems says MEP

(07.04.10) - MEP Promotes EU Teaching Resource

(24.03.10) - MEP Helps small firms beat recession

(02.03.10) - MEP Welcomes Foreign Students to Carmel

(11.02.10) - Healthcare workers - Needlestick Injuries

(02.02.2010) - EU Equality Law

(21.1.10) - Major Boost for Agency Workers

(26.11.09) - Protection for Airline Passengers

(10.11.09)- Unsolicited Direct Marketing Calls

(19.03.09) - No truth - Miss/Mrs

(04.03.09) - fight child pronography

(25.02.09) - Students Northumberland

(11.02.09) - EU Surplus Food Scheme

(11.02.09) - Text CHarge Cuts

(06.02.09) - Beat the scammers

(04.02.09) - No thread for retained fire crews

(04.02.09) - Lindsay workers

(04.01.09) - Nissan - Help from EU

(19.12.08) - Directory Scams

(18.12.08) - Working time

(01.12.08) - CAP

(09.07.08) - North East Fishermen

(26.06.08) - What's Fishy in the Region?

(18.06.08) - Recycling Targets

(17.06.08) - Recycling Targets

(29.04.08) - Conference t on Social Economy

(14.04.08) - Spotlight on China

(12.02.08) - Morpeth Herald on Hotline costs

(25.01.08) - Tougher Toy Standards on the Way

(22.01.08) - Pre-fix telephone number rip off

(22.01.08) - Growth in vulnerable work the focus of the regional TUC